Sandwiched in between the nothingness that is Scott Podsednik and the thunderous roar that is Jim Thome has been the steady, unassuming play of Tadahito Iguchi.

The Emperor, who is pretty much the de facto leadoff man considering Pablo Ozuna and Pods have hit in front of him so far this season, is second on the team in hitting and OBP. In fact, he’s only failed to reach base in one of his six starts this year (and he had a
bit of a tiff with Ozzie because of the one game he’s sat).
The one redeeming part about Pods’ struggles is that we’re getting to see what Iguchi could do if he were hitting lower in the lineup, and the early returns are encouraging. He’s already walked more times than he did last April (five to four), and has only struck out three times in 24 plate appearances. He looks patient, and he’s hitting plenty of line drives.
Hopefully Ozzie’s noticing Iguchi’s output, because if Pods has to go on the DL soon (and given his sickly output, it seems imminent), he’s going to have to reshape his lineup. And having Pablo Ozuna leading off regularly is not my idea of sound lineup construction, so he’ll have to do something he has yet to do:
Bat Iguchi leadoff.
Here’s my thought on lineups – ultimately, you want your best players getting the most at-bats. Having the typical leadoff hitter only means something at the start of each game, because who knows if he’ll start off an inning for the rest of it. On the other hand, you can’t have your best slugger bat leadoff because you want to maximize his homers by having some decent on-base guys in front of him.
Right now, with the way Iguchi is swinging the bat, he’d have no problem leading off. Nobody mentions his speed, but he did steal 15 bases last year just above the break-even rate (75 percent). So there’s really no reason why he couldn’t handle No. 1 duties day after day considering that’s what he‘s doing right now with a gimpy Pods wasting the first at-bat of the game.
The only problem is if you move Iguchi, then you’re going to have to replace him in the No. 2 spot – and there aren’t a lot of good candidates outside of Jermaine Dye, because you need a guy that 1) can get on base and 2) stay out of the double play.
But if he was against pushing Jermaine up ahead of Thome and Paul Konerko, then it’d be a bit of a sticky situation. Brian Anderson needs to be buried in the order, Mackowiak doesn’t handle the bat well, Pierzynski grounds into too many double-plays, Crede has been a low on-base guy his entire career. Maybe Juan Uribe could handle it, but Ozzie’s already passed on the opportunity to bat him second.
And it wouldn’t be better, necessarily, to push Thome up to the No. 2 spot because he’d still be hitting with one or two (relatively) automatic outs in front of him, and then Iguchi…
…unless Ross Gload starts hitting.
In the one year Gload played consistently, he hit .321, walked about once every 10 times, didn’t strike out all that often and showed a little bit of pop. While I’m not too familiar with the career of Rob Mackowiak, I’ve seen enough of his splits to know that neither he nor any other outfielder in the Sox system has had a comparable 230 at-bats in any stretch. And while Gload may be an atrocious outfielder, the others aren’t much better to nullify his bat.
If/when Pods hits the DL, Gload could make a lineup in which Thome hits in the No. 2 spot work – if he hits anywhere close to what he did in 2004. Gload’s OBP was .375, so even a drop in production would make him league average, which Crede and Juan Uribe can’t claim.
Here’s what a lineup would look like with Gload in it:
- R Tadahito Iguchi
- L Jim Thome
- R Paul Konerko
- R Jermaine Dye
- L A.J. Pierzynski
- R Joe Crede
- R Juan Uribe
- R Brian Anderson
- L Ross Gload
(And if you’re playing Mackowiak in center, bat switch his spot and Uribe’s to have better righty-lefty balance)
Here’s why that works:
1. You have two above-average OBPs in front of your best hitters.
2. You’re preserving the heart of the order – it’s just pushed up a slot so they come up one spot sooner.
3. Brian Anderson is still buried.
4. Solid righty-lefty balance
5. No big packs of plodding guys.
Meanwhile with Ozuna playing everyday in a possible Pods absence, Ozzie’s options are far more limited. Ozuna would have to bat seventh in order to 1) make Anderson’s at-bats of the least consequence and 2) get some quality hitters in front of Thome. And even so, a lineup in which a guy like Ozuna is hitting seventh or higher is considerably less threatening. He should be seeing the fewest at-bats per game if it can be helped.
The jury's still out on Mackowiak, who historically is a pure streak hitter.
The chances are most likely slimmer to see Gload starting everyday in Pods’ absence rather than Thome hitting second, but that’s what I would do if I were a manager. Sure, Thome may not seem like a “No. 2 hitter,” but that matters only during the first inning. After that, the only difference between hitting second and hitting third is getting up to the plate one man sooner. Considering Thome is the guy everybody wants to see at the plate, I’d rather the lineup be dependent on him rather than the other way around.